The Best Mattress Pad for You in 2019

pink roses and a book with a cup of coffee sitting on top of a bed

Shopping for a mattress pad isn’t as difficult as it may seem. Whether you are replacing an old one or purchasing a mattress pad for the first time, this guide can help you figure out what a mattress pad is and show you some of the best mattress pads available right now.

​Why Buy a Mattress Pad?

​Before you begin shopping for the best mattress pad, you may be asking some questions. Do you really need one? Do you know what a mattress pad is and why you should own one?

A mattress pad is a thick fitted sheet you place directly on your mattress before you put on your fitted and flat sheets. This specific mattress pad barrier is usually about a half an inch to one inch thick. It offers basic protection and some comfort.

White flowers in a vase on top of a table beside a white bed

A good mattress pad can help extend the life of your mattress, saving you money and hassle over the years.


​While a mattress pad is not a full protector option, it does offer some protection from the daily wear and tear your mattress can receive. Using a mattress pad can cut down on dirt, pet dander, and crumbs in your bed. It also protects against rubbing the mattress fibers which can cause damage or rips.

Debris that can reach your mattress will get caught in the fibers. While ​removing dust and allergens may not seem that difficult, debris on the other hand are tiny particles can be hard and sharp. Buried in the mattress fibers these potentially sharp particles can cut the mattress​​​​ fibers.

If you have pets, then a top rated mattress pad is an even bigger bonus. Beyond being another member of the households, pets bring with them an increased amount of hair. This can ramp up your pet allergies if you have them, but a bed pad can help make it easier to keep this at bay. 

Some mattress pads will offer a waterproof protection to keep spills off your mattress. However, if you are seeking a waterproof cover you will want to search for a mattress protector instead of a pad.


​While it is not very thick, a mattress pad can give you an extra layer of comfort while you sleep. If you are looking for a thick-cushioned cover, you will want to search for a ​mattress topper​.

Mattress pads are normally made with a cotton blend on the outside and offer a variety of inner fillings such as fiberfill, down feathers,​ down alternative and even memory foam.

A quilted seam finish on the top of a mattress pad helps keep the inner fillings evenly spread. It also helps to keep it from getting lumpy after a turn in the wash.

A mattress pad offers the best of both worlds. It offers a protective layer like a mattress protector and has cushion like that of a mattress topper.

If you buy the right one, they aren't hard to clean, and will last you a long time.

pink roses and a book with a cup of coffee sitting on top of a bed

​The Top Rated Mattress Pads

​These three mattress pads are the current bestsellers on Amazon. Take a look at the different features and materials to see which mattress pad would help give you a better night’s sleep and keep your mattress and clean sheets safe.

​Our Top Recommendation

​If you want our final vote, the ​​Leisure Town Overfill ​wins for Best ​Mattress Pad.

Utopia Bedding Quilted Mattress Pad

​Comfortable and affordable, the ​Utopia Bedding Quilted Mattress Pad is a great option to protect your mattress pad while giving you a layer of comfort while you are sleeping.

The super-soft quilted body is filled with a high-loft polyester fiberfill which keeps its fluff and won’t spread out over time. It can add softness to an already comfy bed or make a too firm bed more comfortable.

While you are sleeping, this mattress pad will trap in any excess moisture, so you stay dry and enjoy a good night’s sleep. The cotton-poly blend mattress pad allows airflow through the pad, so you aren’t overheating with the extra layer on your mattress.

For ease of cleaning, just toss this mattress pad into the washer on the delicate or gentle cycles with your other linens. Make sure it gives 2 thorough rinse cycles and skip the bleach. After washing you can hang your mattress pad over the shower rack to air dry or let it tumble on low heat in the dryer.

This mattress pad will fit mattresses up to 16 inches deep and comes in sizes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and a California King.

​Why Buy?

​A mattress pad ​of great value and comfort.

​Leisure Town Overfill Mattress Pad

Comfortable, water-resistant, and a great alternative to down feathers, the ​Leisure Town Overfilled Mattress Pad is a great choice for all around comfort and protection.

This thick quilted mattress pad will add a softer landing when you lay down. Using an alternative to down feather filling this mattress pad offers the feel of goose and duck down feathers without them poking through and avoiding allergy issues.

Due to the thick stitching and padding, spills are easily wiped up. Some spills may soak into the mattress pad. But, unless it is more than six ounces spilling then it won’t soak all the way down to your mattress.

Built into the pad is HNN Cooling Technology, which keeps you from overheating in the summer while keeps you from freezing in the winter. This feature allows for air circulation inside of the mattress pad while you lay on it and reduces sweating.

Machine washable and able to be tumble dried on low heat for easy cleaning and refreshing. You can also try ​washing this with some natural cleaners and it'll do the job just as good.

This mattress pad comes packaged in a vacuumed sealed bag. It is suggested that you lay the mattress pad out for a few days so that it returns to it’s normal size. It will fit any mattress up to 21 inches deep and comes in sizes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and a California King.

​Why Buy?

Thick, comfortable, ​and water absorbent, this pad's a hybrid of pleasure and purpose.

​AmazonBasics Hypoallergenic Mattress Pad

​A breathable, quilted top, and hypoallergenic filling make the​AmazonBasics Hypoallergenic Quilted Mattress Pad one of the best around. This mattress pad is made up of 80% polyester and 20% cotton.

The breathable poly-cotton blended fabric doesn’t trap in heat as you sleep. Instead, it allows airflow to keep your mattress pad cool. Don’t worry about freezing in the winter time. The mattress pad was made to keep you comfortable instead of sweating.

The quilted padding ensures the fiberfill cushion remains evenly displaced throughout the entire mattress pad. The hypoallergenic fiberfill will allow you to rest easy without having any allergy flareups.

This mattress pad will fit mattresses up to 18 inches deep and is able to be purchased for a Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and a California King.

It is also machine washable and able to withstand high heat levels in the dryer to allow for quick and easy refreshing as needed. This mattress pad is super light. Weighing less than 4 pounds, it is easy to take off and put back on, just like a table cloth.

​Why Buy?

​Rest easy knowing this mattress pad traps allergens as you sleep through the night.


Now that you have a better idea of what the best mattress pad consists of and where you can find one, you can shop with confidence. The best mattress pad is one that fits your needs and your bed, so you can sleep comfortably while protecting your mattress.

About the Author Lauren Moldvay

Lauren Moldvay is a freelance writer from Virginia and the mother of one (not always) sweet little girl. She specializes in trying to help others find easier ways to clean, manage the home and save money with DIY projects.

Leave a Comment: